I always start by patting the feta dry with a paper towel to remove excess moisture. Wet feta won't caramelize as nicely, so this step matters more than it seems. I usually leave it wrapped while the oven preheats to 400°F.
Lightly oil the bottom of your baking dish so the feta doesn't stick. Place the block right in the center and drizzle olive oil evenly over the top and sides. I try to cover the whole surface so nothing dries out.
Slide the dish into the oven and bake for 8-10 minutes, until the feta looks warm and slightly soft to the touch. It shouldn't be melting, just softened enough that it's easy to press a spoon into later.
Pull the dish out and drizzle honey generously over the top. Switch your oven to high broil and pop it back in for 2-4 minutes. I stand right by the oven for this part since broilers work fast and honey can burn quickly.
Once the top turns golden and slightly bubbly, take the dish out and let it sit for a minute. Sprinkle pepper, herbs, or any add-ins like walnuts on top. Serve it warm while the center is still soft and spreadable.