I start by dropping the torn basil and mint leaves into my glass. Using my muddler, I press down gently a few times, just enough to bruise the leaves and release their oils. I never crush too hard here, since that can make the drink taste bitter instead of fresh.
Next, I pour in my fresh lime juice and simple syrup right over the muddled herbs. I like to give it a quick stir at this point so the syrup doesn't just sit at the bottom of the glass once I add ice.
I fill the glass about three-quarters of the way with ice. I always use plenty of ice here since it keeps the mocktail cold as I top it off and stir, without diluting the herby, citrusy base too quickly.
Using my long bar spoon, I stir the ice, herbs, and liquid together really well. This step matters more than people think, since it distributes the basil and mint flavor evenly through the whole glass instead of leaving it pooled at the bottom.
I pour the chilled sparkling water over the top, leaving about an inch of room so I can give it one last gentle stir. I try not to stir too vigorously here, since I don't want to lose all that lovely fizz.
Finally, I top my mocktail with a few extra basil and mint leaves and a lime wedge or wheel. I like to give the leaves a light clap between my hands first, which really wakes up their aroma right before serving.