I start by adding the pumpkin puree, brown sugar, maple syrup, and apple cider straight into my saucepan. I whisk everything together until it's smooth and there are no lumps of sugar left. This only takes a minute or two, and it's the easiest part of the whole process.
Next, I sprinkle in the cinnamon, ginger, cloves, nutmeg, and salt. I whisk again so the spices distribute evenly instead of clumping in one spot. This step is where the kitchen really starts to smell incredible, even before the heat goes on.
I place the saucepan over medium heat and bring everything to a gentle simmer, then immediately lower the heat. I let it bubble softly for about 20-25 minutes, stirring every couple of minutes so it doesn't stick or scorch on the bottom.
As it cooks, I watch for the mixture to darken slightly and thicken to where it coats the back of a spoon. If it's still loose after 25 minutes, I keep simmering a bit longer, since it needs to reduce enough to hold its shape when cooled.
Once it's thick, I pull the pot off the heat and let the pumpkin butter cool completely on the counter before transferring it to jars. It thickens even more as it cools, so I never judge the final texture while it's still warm.