Go Back
Halloween French Toast Recipe
Ash Tyrrell

Halloween French Toast Recipe

I still remember the morning after Halloween when my kitchen counter was buried under a mountain of leftover candy nobody could finish. Instead of letting it all go stale in a drawer, I started tucking chunks of chocolate bars between slices of thick bread and turning the whole thing into a gooey, golden French toast sandwich.
Print Recipe Pin Recipe
Prep Time 10 minutes
Cook Time 15 minutes
Servings: 4
Ingredients Method Notes

Ingredients
  

  • 8 slices thick white or brioche bread – I use a sturdy slightly stale loaf so it holds the filling without falling apart
  • 3 large eggs – these bind the custard and give the toast its rich golden color
  • 3/4 cup whole milk – whole milk makes the custard creamier than skim or low-fat versions
  • 2 tablespoons granulated sugar – just enough to sweeten the base without competing with the candy
  • 1 teaspoon vanilla extract – adds warmth and rounds out the flavor of the egg mixture
  • 1/2 teaspoon ground cinnamon – gives that cozy fall-morning aroma I always want in October
  • 1/4 teaspoon salt – balances the sweetness so the dish doesn't taste flat
  • 1 cup chopped leftover Halloween candy chocolate bars work best – pick candy that melts well, not hard candies
  • 3 tablespoons unsalted butter – for frying since butter gives the best crisp, golden crust
  • Powdered sugar for dusting – a simple finishing touch that makes the plate look bakery-worthy

Method
 

  1. I start by roughly chopping my leftover Halloween candy into small pieces so it melts evenly once the sandwich hits the skillet. Chocolate bars, peanut butter cups, and caramel-filled candies all work beautifully here. I avoid anything too hard, like lollipops, since they won't soften in time.
  2. In a large bowl, I whisk together the eggs, milk, sugar, vanilla, cinnamon, and salt until everything looks smooth and pale yellow. This only takes about a minute, but it's the step that gives the toast its flavor, so I never rush through it.
  3. Next, I lay out my bread slices and scatter the chopped candy evenly over half of them, then top with the remaining slices to form sandwiches. I press down gently so the candy stays put and doesn't spill out the sides once it starts melting.
  4. I dip each candy sandwich into the egg mixture for just a few seconds per side. I don't let it soak too long, or the bread turns mushy and falls apart in the pan. A quick, even coating is really all you need here.
  5. I melt butter in my skillet over medium heat, then fry each sandwich for about three to four minutes per side. I watch closely and flip once the underside turns a deep golden brown, which also gives the candy inside time to melt completely.
  6. Once they're done, I let the sandwiches sit for a minute so the melted candy doesn't burn little mouths. Then I slice them diagonally, dust them with powdered sugar, and get them on plates while they're still warm and slightly gooey inside.

Notes

  • I always use bread that's a day or two old because fresh bread gets soggy way too fast in the custard.
  • I keep my skillet at medium heat instead of high, since high heat browns the outside before the candy inside has time to melt.
  • I like mixing different candy types in one sandwich for pockets of caramel, chocolate, and nougat in every bite.
  • I press the sandwiches gently with my spatula while frying so the filling sets and the bread crisps evenly.
  • I prep my egg mixture the night before so breakfast comes together in minutes on a busy morning.