Go Back
Tiramisu Cups Recipe
Ash Tyrrell

Tiramisu Cups Recipe

I made these tiramisu cups for a small dinner party last month, and honestly, I haven't stopped making them since. I love that I can prep everything the night before and just pull them out of the fridge when my guests arrive. There's no baking, no fussing with raw eggs, and no stress about getting the layers "just right" in one giant dish
Total Time 2 hours 20 minutes

Ingredients
  

  • Strong brewed coffee ¾ cup – I use espresso here since it gives the deepest flavor without watering down the cups.
  • Sweet marsala wine 2 tablespoons – this is what gives classic tiramisu its signature warmth, though it's easy to skip if you want a kid-friendly version.
  • Heavy whipping cream 1 cup – grab cream with a high fat content and keep it cold; it whips up so much better that way.
  • Instant espresso powder 1 teaspoon – I mix a little into the cream itself for an extra coffee kick in every bite.
  • Vanilla extract 1 teaspoon – I always use real extract here, never imitation, since it makes a noticeable difference in flavor.
  • Powdered sugar ½ cup – it dissolves smoothly into the cream without any graininess.
  • Mascarpone cheese 1 cup – this soft Italian cheese is what makes the filling so silky, and I always let mine sit at room temperature for a few minutes before mixing.
  • Savoiardi ladyfingers 12 cookies – these Italian sponge biscuits soak up the coffee beautifully; I always check for a sturdy Italian-made brand.
  • Cocoa powder for dusting – a light sieve of this on top right before serving finishes the look perfectly.

Method
 

  1. I start by brewing my coffee and letting it cool down completely, since warm coffee will melt the cream layers later. Once it's cool, I pour it into a shallow dish and stir in the marsala wine. This mixture is what gives the ladyfingers their signature bold flavor.
  2. Using my hand mixer, I whip the cold heavy cream together with the powdered sugar and instant espresso powder. I only whip it until soft peaks form, since I know I'll be mixing it again once the mascarpone goes in.
  3. In a separate bowl, I stir the mascarpone cheese with the vanilla extract until it's smooth and a little looser. This little step makes it so much easier to fold into the whipped cream without lumps.
  4. I add the mascarpone mixture into the whipped cream and whisk just until it turns firm and holds its shape. I always watch closely here, because overmixing at this stage is the easiest way to ruin the texture.
  5. I cut each ladyfinger in half and dip them briefly into the coffee mixture, then place two halves at the bottom of each glass. I spoon a generous layer of the mascarpone cream on top, then repeat with another layer of dipped ladyfingers and cream.
  6. Once all six cups are layered, I cover them with plastic wrap and pop them in the fridge for at least two hours. This chilling time lets the flavors meld together and helps the layers firm up nicely.
  7. Right before serving, I sieve a light dusting of cocoa powder over the top of each cup. This final touch is what makes them look like they came straight from an Italian bakery.

Notes

  • I always start with cream that's very cold, since warm cream just won't whip up properly.
  • I never rush the dipping step for the ladyfingers. A quick dunk leaves them dry, so I let them soak up a bit more coffee than I initially think they need.
  • I stop mixing the mascarpone cream the second it holds firm peaks, because a few extra seconds can cause it to curdle.
  • I like to taste my coffee mixture before dipping, since bitterness varies a lot between coffee brands.
  • I prep my glasses and ingredients ahead of time so the assembly step goes smoothly without any rushing.